You’ve Lost That Loving Feeling

dating, relationships, humor, Modern PhilosopherI’m beginning to think I’m horrible at dating, Modern Philosophers.

I know what you want to say:  It took you this long to realize that, Austin???

Good one.  All joking aside, though, I was giving it some thought this morning during my run, and I came to the conclusion that I needed to blog about it, as that is much cheaper than therapy.

Then something else happened.

A friend was texting earlier, and I suggested bringing someone to Thanksgiving dinner, which prompted her to ask: Is that really a good first date? 

I replied, quite honestly, that I don’t remember what a good first date is.

I’m pretty sure I know the source of my problem.

Ooo, ooo, I know the answer to that one!  The problem is you, Austin!

Well, clearly it’s me, but I believe I’ve found the true root of the issue.  I might be looking for something that simply doesn’t exist.

Here’s the thing…whenever I meet someone new who intrigues me, I get all excited about the getting to know her process.  I love the texting, emailing, flirting, laughing, and making plans to get together for that first date.

Up to that point, I’m giddy, hopeful, and my inner hopeless romantic does a little happy dance to the beat of a heart that’s pumping a little faster because of all the excitement.

Then we meet, and it all goes horribly wrong.

And it’s very rarely because of something bad that happens on the date (although that one time comes to mind when my date removed the ice cube from her empty glass, and began to wipe down the table with it without giving any explanation for her actions).

dating, relationships, humor, Modern PhilosopherIt’s pretty much always because of what’s missing during those encounters.

There’s this feeling I used to get whenever I was around The Girl Who Moved Away.  Even before we started dating, I’d feel it whenever she came into the room, or I heard her voice, or she sent an email.

I can remember the very first time I ever saw her.  I was a temp at a new job, sorting mail at the front desk.  It was mindless work, and I was bored out of my mind, and considering asking the temp agency for a new gig when she came through the front door.

She wore a baggy sweatshirt and sweatpants, no make up, and her hair was in a messy pony tail.  She smiled at me, and walked into the office like she belonged there.

I didn’t know who she was, but for some reason, I needed to know.  Immediately.  I sought out someone and asked her who the smiling, extremely casually dressed woman was.

I was told she worked in the office, but was on vacation, which was why I hadn’t met her.

That happened eight years ago, but I can still see it all in my head as clearly as if it were happening right now for the first time.  And my heart beats faster at the memory.

I don’t remember the exact first moment I met my ex-wife, or anyone else I’ve ever dated.

When I think back to my other relationships, be it the big time ones, or just the little ones, I never had that feeling I felt when I was around The Girl Who Moved Away.

So perhaps it’s unfair to every other woman I meet, to expect to have that feeling again, but this is where I get confused.

Was that the feeling of true love?  If so, shouldn’t I want to find it again?  Wouldn’t I be doing myself a disservice if I settled for anything less?

dating, relationships, humor, Modern PhilosopherThese are genuine questions, Modern Philosophers.  I’m not trying to be funny.

When I was married, I thought the feelings I had for J were true love.  I’d never felt that way about another woman, so that was why I was certain she was my special someone.

After our divorce, I worried that I’d never feel about another woman the way I felt for J.  And for the longest time, I didn’t.  I clearly remember crying like a baby in the car on my way home from my first post-divorce date.

I’d felt nothing on that date.  I just wanted J.  And that was a few months after the divorce, so I can understand the longing for a feeling I’d known for 18 years.

But it is five years since The Girl moved away, and I’m still longing for that loving feeling.

And it’s not lost on me that this second relationship proved that I hadn’t known what true love felt like all those years during my mariage.  So my mind is open to the possibility that there is someone out there who will make feel something different, better, deeper.

By the same token, however, I also realize that I might have had true love and allowed it to slip through my fingers.  Perhaps that relationship was lightning in a bottle, my one in a million, the happiness I was so blessed to experience.

dating, relationships, humor, Modern PhilosopherMaybe I’m a fool for continuing to look for it because it was a once in a lifetime moment that will not be repeated.

This is why I am so torn.  Logic dictates that if I found true love, I can find it again, and should never give up my quest for the magic that is life changing.

But logic also nudges at me, and whispers that lightning rarely strikes twice.  I should just find someone who makes me happy, and not look for a repeat of a love I ultimately lost.

Regardless of what the correct answer is, the constant internal debate makes dating very difficult.  Part of me will never stop looking for that incredible feeling.  Another part thinks it walked into my life in a baggy sweatshirt and sweatpants eight years ago, and I should just stop trying to find that which I’ve already discovered.

Simply put, I’m lost.

Bring back that loving feeling because it’s gone, gone, gone…

Any advice, Modern Philosophers?

About Austin

Native New Yorker who's fled to the quiet life in Maine. I write movies, root for the Yankees, and shovel lots of snow.
This entry was posted in Dating, Humor and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

18 Responses to You’ve Lost That Loving Feeling

  1. grannyK says:

    I keep trying to figure out something to say, but I am no help. I lost my husband 27 years ago. I dated now and then, but it just wasn’t the same. I think ultimately, it is up to you if you want to keep searching for the perfect someone again or not. I decided years ago to stop looking and I have been okay with that. I wasn’t really “looking” for someone when I met my husband, so you just never know when it can happen. I believe if you are trying way too hard to find true love, it will not happen because you are trying to force it. Just some thoughts of mine.

    • Austin says:

      I’m sorry for your loss, and thank you for your input. I know I would like to find someone because this being single thing is no fun. I’m just not sure if I should “settle”, or keep seeking out that amazing feeling I had when The Girl was in my life…

  2. Ashana M says:

    No advice, but I feel your pain…

  3. markbialczak says:

    Oh, my friend Austin. I think you have to partially disconnect that overactive brain of yours, let the past stay in the rear view, stop comparing new things with old, and appreciate what comes in moments on their own.

  4. Ocean Bream says:

    Sometimes what you may think of as ‘settling’ may not be settling at all. And sometimes that special feeling takes time to manifest. So why forsake what could be amazing because you haven’t felt an instant connection? With my ‘first love’ there was an instant connection. That didnt work out because it was toxic but with my now husband, well I spend the majority of my life knowing him and not thinking he was anything special until I began to date him and even then it took a very long time. Now I know that what I feel for him cannot be matched by anything I ever felt before. That is just my opinion though. I feel your pain and frustration!

  5. beth says:

    never give up and look ahead. let it be.

  6. AAristizabal says:

    Austin, we never “let anything (or anyone, for that case) slip through our fingers”: people, things, feelings, etc. happen in our lives for a reason: we need to outgrow them, to be better at them. People we meet, people we lose, people we grow with, they all play a role and are part of something way bigger than ourselves. Hang on there, one day you will see everything and everyone is connected (whether you believe or not in God), and is leading you onto something or someone that is just right for you. Hang in there, and do the right thing.

  7. Trishana says:

    Austin, decades ago I broke up with someone I should have married, because I wasn’t “in love.” Of course, I can’t say if it would have worked, but in the years since I have recognized that he was the most perfect partner for me that I ever knew. What I have learned is that emotions are there to support love, not create it. If a long term partner is truly important to you, find someone who shares your values and habits. True love is about loyalty and commitment, not dopamine. Our modern society has lost sight of this. Dante was happily married but longed forever for the unattainable Beatrice, his muse and romantic love. Sometimes that is how it is. Use these feelings to propel your art.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s